Check the Status of Your Ticket

New Lights On S Water St Are Too Bright

Email: speightsjason@gmail.com
Name: Jason Speights
Phone Number: 575 517 0987
Status: Closed
Assigned To: estahlman (General)
Ticket ID: ea14

Dear City of Frostburg,

The new lights on South Water Street are too bright for a residential area. They are about 20 times brighter than the previous ones. They are about as bright as ambient daylight when measured inside our house near the windows, so half of our house is effectively in daylight conditions for 24 hrs of the day. The lights are so bright that they directly illuminate large portions of the inside of our house, including the bedrooms.

There are also reasons for concern about how this negatively affects the local wildlife in the neighborhood, what use to be a dark enough sky to see the stars, property values, and safety. I've documented some of the changes and their impact on the neighborhood.

I'm happy to meet to discuss these concerns in further detail and work together to resolve them.

With kind regards,

Dr. Jason Speights

Ticket History

Public
Closed
Updated By: estahlman
Assigned To: estahlman (General)
03/09/2022 - 10:14am
Public
Open
Updated By: Visitor
Assigned To: estahlman (General)

Hi Elizabeth,

I'm available. I appreciate you being willing to hear me out.

Thanks,

Jason

02/14/2022 - 6:37pm
Public
Open
Updated By: estahlman
Assigned To: estahlman (General)

Hello,

Thank you for the additional information.  Would you be available to meet this Thursday at 6:00 pm?  

02/14/2022 - 11:19am
Public
Open
Updated By: Visitor
Assigned To: estahlman (General)
02/09/2022 - 7:34pm
Public
Open
Updated By: Visitor
Assigned To: estahlman (General)

Hi Elizabeth,

Your quick reply is greatly appreciated. I'm glad to hear that you'll try to help us out.

Our address is 39 S Water St. There are 5 street lights and a parking lot light that illuminate the inside of our house. These are the 5 street lights starting from the corner of Ormand and S Water St heading towards Frost Avenue. The lights are so bright that even the 3 lights further away illuminate the middle bedroom, and because of the different angles through the window, almost an entire wall is lit up in that room. The one that is 2nd furthest away out of those 5 illuminates the inside of the rear bedroom. The parking lot light is the floodlight in the parking lot of the Police Station and City Hall. There is a mirror in that light that points directly into our rooms with bay windows, one of which is a master bedroom.

I still have other concerns of the effect the lights are having on the neighborhood. If you walk S Water St at night, for example, it's trivial to see that these lights are shining directly into peoples houses and through their yards, and the effect often looks like it is worse than what we are experiencing. Would you or someone in your office be interested in meeting me at the corner of Ormand and S Water St and walking a small part of S Water St shortly after it gets dark to see these effects? My hunch is that other residents may not know how to start a conversation if it is affecting them too.

I completely understand other residents safety concerns.  I have experience working with local governments on safe lighting and light pollution. A common misperception is that brighter and bluer light is safer than dimmer and redder light. The way that our eyes process light makes the opposite true. To demonstrate this notice how your ability to see on either side of the street is dramatically diminished when someone drives past you going the other way with brighter and bluer headlights pointed at you compared to the headlights that are dimmer and redder. For example, if a police officer were to drive down S Water St it would be easier for someone to hide in a shadow, or go unseen if trying to break into the side of a house, because the officer's eyes would be unable to see outside of the light cones of those street lights. Likewise, with dimmer and redder lights it is much harder for someone to hide in a shadow because the potential victim won't have their "night vision" too diminished to see what's lurking in the shadows. I can elaborate on the biophysics if interested.

I imagine the city spent quite a lot of money on those new lights. Sometimes those come with ways to adjust the brightness and the color, or are easily modified to do so. Whoever installed them would probably know. Also you might consider moving those to other parts of the city that you are planning to upgrade with new street lights, and replace the ones on S Water St with ones that aren't so bright and blue. In this case, if you would like to provide me with the specifications, I would be more than happy do some research and recommend some options for replacements.

Please let me know if there is anything that I can do to be of assistance.

Sincerely,

Jason

02/09/2022 - 4:19pm
Public
Open
Updated By: estahlman
Assigned To: estahlman (General)

Hello,

Would you please send your address and we can install a shade on the light so it does not shine directly into your house.  

Residents have been requesting that these lights be replaced.  They were LED lights previously as well, but the LED lights do not "burn out", but rather dim.  They had "dimmed" beyond their rated life span and were providing little to no public safety benefit.

Thank you,

Elizabeth Stahlman

City Administrator

02/08/2022 - 1:47pm
New
Assigned To:

Citizen request/question created.

02/08/2022 - 11:23am

Disclosures

Certain messages sent through this form may constitute a public record and be subject to disclosure under state law.

Communications sent via the Internet or through this Web page shall in no way be deemed to constitute legal notice to the City or any of its officers, agents, or employees, where notice to the City is required by any law, rule, regulation or contract.